“it is said”与“it has been said”在语义表达上的核心区别在于对动作“said”的时间强调和影响侧重不同,具体如下:
一、核心语义差异
结构 | 语义重点 | 使用场景 |
|————————|—————————————————————————–|—————————————————————————–|
it is said that | 强调“所说内容是当前被普遍认可的事实”,不突出“说”的动作发生时间。| 陈述客观流传的信息,不强调信息的来源或“说”的动作对现在的直接影响。 |
it has been said that | 强调“said这一动作已经发生,且对现在造成影响或结果”。 | 突出信息“被说过”这一动作的完成性,暗示该说法可能持续存在或与当前情况相关。 |
二、具体用法与例句对比
1. it is said that
特点:一般现在时,聚焦于“内容的客观性”,而非动作的时间。
例句:
It is said that she lived to be over 100.(据说她活了100多岁。)[1]
It is said that this medicine can alleviate pain.(据说这种药物能够缓解疼痛。)
2. it has been said that
特点:现在完成时,强调“动作完成”及“对现在的影响”。
例句:
It has been said that Egypt is the home of the comic strip.(人们曾说埃及是连环画的发源地。)
It has been said that the only difference between a drug and a poison is the dose.(有人说,药物和毒物的唯一区别是剂量。)
三、关键区别总结
时间与影响:
“it is said”:中性陈述,不涉及“说”的具体时间,仅表明内容当前被认可。
“it has been said”:强调“说”的动作已完成,且该说法可能至今仍有影响或被提及。
语气强度:
“it has been said”比“it is said”语气稍强,隐含“该说法存在一定历史或共识基础”。
四、记忆口诀
客观事实用一般(it is said),动作完成影响现(it has been said)。
通过语境中是否需要突出“动作完成”和“对现在的影响”,可快速判断两者的使用场景。
发布于 江苏
